I actually have one of the boards that when issuing “shutdown now -r”. About 1 time in 3, the board will not power back up - Well, not properly anyway. ethernet will continue blinking, power LED is on, but the USR LEDs do not do their normal thing. Trying to ssh in, is futile.
This same board, when using “reboot” has not shown these same symptoms, and this is probably a software problem as I’ve noticed that it has been getting worst over time. For instance, this would only happen maybe 1 in 20 reboots a year or more ago.
The board is an A5A . . . and yeah not going to RMA it, but I would not mind testing . . .
The one needling RMA is the flashing power LED. The issue you describe does sounds like a SW issue of sorts, but is not one I have heard of that often.
That might be ok if I wanted to halt the system, But what about when I want to reboot ? shutdown now -h has never had a problem in either case. For me at any rate.